Government decided in 2008 not to introduce a badger cull as part of bovine tb control measures. Assessing the effects of the first 2 years of industry. Whilst the rspca agrees action is needed to deal with bovine tb we do not believe culling badgers is an effective way to achieve this. This in turn led to the first official badger culling programmes in britain, which initially involved gassing of badger. Oct 06, 2012 pdf on oct 6, 2012, iain mcgill and others published bovine tb and badger culling find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. In britain, european badgers meles meles are implicated in transmitting mycobacterium bovis, the causative agent of bovine tuberculosis tb, to cattle. Badger culling has been employed for the control of tb in cattle in both countries, with varying results. The discovery of a dead badger infected with tb on a cattle farm in gloucestershire in 1971 ignited the debate about the role of badgers in transmitting bovine tb to cattle and being a wildlife reservoir of the disease. Faqs about bovine tb in cattle and badger culling tb free. Tb control efforts still entail slaughtering many thousands of cattle annually, costing british farmers and taxpayers millions of dollars.
Badger culling and bovine tb in cattle juniper publishers. The governments policy on bovine tb and badger control in england. However, he should have looked further back before declaring that the badger cull policy is not evidence based. Vaccinating cattle is an effective way of treating cattle. Badger culling trial rbct, 238% of badgers had infection detectable by bacterial culture at standard necropsy 29. Impacts of widespread badger culling on cattle tuberculosis. Final report of the independent scientific group on cattle tb, published in 2007, the group concluded. Mass culling of badgers is at the heart of englands tb policy.
The roi made badger culling a significant part of its eradication programme and it has been claimed that this explains the continued low trend. Bovine tuberculosis btb is a very important disease of cattle in great. Get information on current tb restriction rules, risk areas, the badger cull and vaccination developments. In the uk, badgers meles meles are culled in efforts to reduce badger. The solution to the bovine tb epidemic is likely to be multifaceted.
Bovine tb is a devastating disease affecting cattle across the uk. The eradication programme also includes reducing bovine tb through controls on cattle, advising farmers on herd biosecurity and husbandry measures, funding the development of tb vaccines for cattle and badgers, helping other industry sectors to deal with tb in non bovine. Two pilot culls were implemented in 20 and 2014 in somerset and gloucestershire, extended to three pilot culls in 2015 with the inclusion of dorset. Cull areas comparison areas tb hub bovine tb advice. We believe there are solutions that will benefit farmers, cattle and badgers. Pdf bovine tuberculosis and badger culling in england. Mass badger culls to be phased out and replaced with. Protection of badgers act 1992 and the wildlife and countryside act 1981 to enable farmers andor landowners to cull badgers for the purpose of preventing the spread of bovine tb in cattle.
As implemented, the rbct cannot prove that badgers are not involved in bovine tb transmission to cattle. The incidence of tb in cattle and wildlife varies across the uk, and as such the control of bovine tb btb is approached differently among the devolved administrations, with different policies on badger control and tb. Tb control efforts still entail slaughtering many thousands of cattle annually, costing british farmers and taxpayers millions of. The badger cull is one of the main strategies for the high risk area, to halt and then reverse the increasing prevalence of btb by addressing the disease in cattle and in badgers. The analysis compares a badger culling policy that achieves a 19% reduction in bovine tb incidence, a badger vaccination model achieving a 12. The political economy of bovine tuberculosis in great britain. However, culling has previously been associated with both increased and decreased incidence of. Industryled culling began in somerset and gloucestershire between august and november 20 to reduce local badger populations. The paper challenges the randomised badger culling trial rbct finding that proactive badger culling can influence rates of new herd breakdown. Killing badgers is not an effective way of treating cattle.
Roger blowey might consider the cited recent reference1 covering trial blindness and david kings input. Bovine tuberculosis btb is a bacterial disease of cattle, caused by the. Industryled culling is not designed to be a randomized and con. It is caused by the bacterium mycobacterium bovis m. The sussex wildlife trust does not support a cull of badgers. Pdf bovine tuberculosis and badger control in britain. Badger cull to be replaced by vaccines in bovine tb fight. The several trials at thornbury, steeple leaze, hartland point and the. Bovine tuberculosis btb, and especially the policies enacted to tackle it, can have. The independent scientific group isg on cattle tb, a group containing some of.
Zsl does not support the governments policy of culling badgers in an attempt to control cattle tb. In response to correspondence in last weeks issue on the role of badgers in bovine tb btb vr, 22 june 2019, vol 184, p 774775. In the british isles badgers are often infected by bovine tb and there is substantial evidence that they may be a cause of infection in cattle. Research, published in scientific reports, reports a reduction in bovine tb rates in areas surrounding badger culls prof rosie woodroffe, senior research fellow, zoological society of london zsl, said. Bovine tuberculosis bovine tb is an important and controversial animal health policy issue in england, which impacts humans, cattle and badgers. Badger culling is a doubleedged tool, according to an 8year experiment that began in 1998. Badgers bovine tuberculosis disease control culling great britain policy. The link between tuberculosis in cattle and in badgers has long been contentious. Methods need to be based on available scientific evidence and expert opinion. Fed on monocultures of grass heavily chemically npk fertilised. Assessing effects from four years of industryled badger.
The eurasian badger meles meles is implicated in the transmission of bovine tuberculosis tb to cattle in the uk and republic of ireland. Control of bovine tb has proved difficult in countries where there is a wildlife reservoir for the disease. Aug 04, 2017 culling badgers to control the transmission of bovine tuberculosis tb between this wildlife reservoir and cattle has been widely debated. These apparently contradictory findings were explained in a follow up study which found that the culling of badgers disrupts their territorial behaviour. The interim conclusions from these trials found that proactive culling where as many badgers as possible are culled, and not only in response to tb outbreaks reduced the incidence of bovine tb by 19% within the cull area, but increased it by 29% up to 2km outside the cull area.
It ignores all the scientific evidence that indicates a cull will not achieve this. A reevaluation of proactive culling benefit in the randomized badger culling trial. However, culling has previously been associated with both increased and decreased incidence of m. Transmission from wild badgers impedes control of cattle tb, but nonselective badger culls confer limited benefits because culling changes badger behavior in ways that increase disease. Because badgers are clearly a contributing factor to the uks tb problem, successive tb control policies have included culling of badgers 7, 8. Jun 24, 2014 bovine tuberculosis tb killed 1,500 people annually in 1930s britain.
This concluded that a reactive cull of badgers resulted in significant increases in bovine tb and a. A previous randomised controlled trial suggests that largescale culling can somewhat reduce cattle tb in the short term, but can contribute little to longterm eradication because it increases tb prevalence in badgers and spreads infection to new areas. As originally envisioned, badger densities would have been reduced to near zero in proactive sites. Apr 03, 2017 a quid pro quo closer to tory principles would be to fund some badger culling but withdraw compensation for farmers if they have been shut down by bovine tb for, say, five years. The trial concluded that a reactive cull of badgers resulted in significant increases in bovine tb and a proactive cull, while controlling tb in the cull area, contributed to an increase in tb in surrounding areas, and would not be cost effective. The government policy of badger culling has led to widespread opposition, in part due to the conclusions of a large field trial recommending against culling, and in part because badgers are a cherished wildlife species. It cannot be purely coincidental that this combination of measures is having the effect of reducing the effects of bovine tb. Bovine tuberculosis oxford martin school university of oxford. A follow up to the initial evaluation of the association of badger control and cattle tb incidence by brunton. Patterns of infection in cattle and badgers are closely associated 6 and, in britain, cattle based tb controls have been supplemented with various forms of badger culling 1,7,8. Badger culls reduce bovine tb cattle outbreaks, study finds. Positive and negative effects of widespread badger culling. Largescale badger culling is industryled, but costs taxpayers 36 times as much as it costs farmers.
In recent years bovine tuberculosis tb incidence in cattle has been increasing in south. Effect of culling on individual badger meles meles. Evaluation of the effect of the badger control policy requires consideration of other factors that could affect cattle tb incidence in addition to culling, which is the purpose of the multivariable analyses. Bovine tuberculosis bovine tb is an important animal health policy issue in britain, which impacts farmers, the public, domestic farmed cattle and the wild badger population. Nearly 20,000 badgers culled in attempt to reduce bovine tb. The scientific analysis of data by downs et al assessed the. Tb incidence in cattle in the cull areas which were sustained for an average of 2. Cattle trials are to be implemented and intensive badger culling will end to tackle bovine tb by helena horton 5 march 2020 10. Known as the krebs report, the 1997 paper concluded that there was a lack of evidence to support or discredit the use of badger culling to control the spread of bovine tuberculosis. October 11, 2019 expert reaction to study on rates of cattle tb and the badger cull. When done effectively, it can reduce bovine tb inside the control zone, but incidence is likely to. The resulting bovine tb strategy for england was published in april 20. Badger culling trial rbct, showed that proactively reducing.
We do not believe this will deliver a significant and sustained reduction in tb in cattle. That and movement controls have continued to play a part in disease control but until culling of badgers was permitted, there was a continuation of bovine tb in the national cattle herd. Tb was first identified in badgers in the uk in 1971. More than 100,000 badgers slaughtered in discredited cull. Cagetrapping and dispatch of badgers under licence to.
As a result, large numbers of badgers have died in culling especially in the past 50 years. Badger culls to be phased out in favour of vaccinations. Until now, badger culling in a number of counties in the uk was used as the sole method of attempting to control the disease, which has been highly damaging to the beef and dairy industries. Badger culling trial rbct also known as the krebs trial took place between 1998 and 2006. The previous government decided in 2008 not to introduce a badger cull as part of bovine tb control measures in light of the findings of the uk randomised badger culling trial. Bovine tb is gbs biggest endemic animal health issue, costing the taxpayer around. Culling wildlife as a form of disease management can have unexpected and sometimes counterproductive outcomes. This is in part because the independent scientific group advised against culling. Many farmers argued that culling was a necessary measure to protect the industries. Some believe that badgers play a large part in the spread of bovine tb amongst cattle. Dairy cows, bovine tb and badgers back tb food inc an imal abuse inc dr hamer said pulmonary lung tuberculosis in humans is deathanxiety conflict.
The total has dismayed animal rights campaigners, who claim that for the first time since the cull was introduced in 20, more badgers were shot last year than cattle were slaughtered because. While recognising that badgers can and do transmit tb to cattle, we note that the best estimates indicate that approximately 6% of tbaffected cattle herds become. Tom langton vr, 8 june 2019, vol 184, p 715 rightly takes issue with the modelled data from the randomised badger culling trial rbct. Another line of evidence is that the prevalence of bovine tb infection among badgers culled following bovine tb outbreaks in cattle is higher than among those killed in road traffic accidents. The report concluded these results, combined with evaluation of alternative culling methods, suggest that badger culling is unlikely to contribute effectively to the control of cattle tb in britain.
Dec 21, 2017 the effectiveness of culling badgers on reducing bovine tb in cattle is disputed, but defra cited a recent academic paper showing there was less cattle tb in cull zones in somerset and. In the 1970s, when licensed culling of badgers first started, the rspca sat on. The culling of badgers in two areas of england has been linked to a marked decrease in new cases of bovine tb on farms, research suggests, bolstering farmers who support the culls. Culling badgers to control the transmission of bovine tuberculosis tb between this wildlife reservoir and cattle has been widely debated. Badger culling has modest effect in cutting cattle tb. But it adds that the policy would lead to more than 40,000 badgers. The problem will stop when an effective means of treating cattle has been found. It was designed by the independent scientific group on cattle tb isg, to investigate how btb spread between cattle, badgers and other wildlife. Largescale nonselective culling may help control cattle tb, but it cannot eradicate tb because it increases prevalence among badgers and spreads tb to cattle in new areas. Badger culling in the united kingdom is permitted under licence, within a set area and timescale, as a way to reduce badger numbers in the hope of controlling the spread of bovine tuberculosis btb humans can catch btb, but public health control measures, including milk pasteurisation and the bcg vaccine, mean it is not a significant risk to human health. Badger culling and bovine tb house of commons library. The duration of the effects of repeated widespread badger. Results from northern ireland also suggested there was a positive association between the the number of active main setts and the risk of a bovine tb. These are licences for areas that have successfully completed a licenced 4year intensive cull.
The bovine tb eradication group for england 2008 in november 2008, the bovine tb eradication group for england was set up. The westminster governments badger culling policy in england, which began in 20, has caused considerable controversy. We dont support the badger cull and believe that more can be done to tackle the disease in cattle. Third, significance bovine tuberculosis tb killed 1,500 people annually in 1930s britain. What followed was the randomised badger culling trials rbct, where 11,000 badgers were. It provides recommendations on best practice and highlights those areas of the technique that must be complied with, including licence conditions. Effect of culling on individual badger meles meles behaviour. This was disputed by some experts, and the effectiveness of badger culling as a means of controlling btb remains contentious.
Since then a range of culling strategies have been employed with the aim of controlling the disease, including a large field experiment called the randomised badger culling trial rbct or krebs trial. Badger responses to smallscale culling may compromise. Cullinginduced social perturbation in eurasian badgers. In britain and ireland, control is hampered by a reservoir of infection in eurasian badgers meles meles. The wildlife trusts have opposed the badger cull since it first started and no wildlife trust will allow badger culling on its land.
Based on the scientific evidence available we do not believe that culling a protected species is the right approach to tackling bovine tb. The disease is zoonotic, meaning it can be transmitted from animals to humans. Bovine tuberculosis btb is an infectious disease of cattle and one of the biggest challenges facing the farming industry today. Assessing the effects of the first 2 years of industryled badger culling in england on the incidence of bovine tuberculosis in cattle in 202015. Licences to trap and vaccinate badgers would also continue to be available. May 10, 2020 badger culling, as a bovine tb policy measure, is a devolved matter. Continued surveillance of cattle herds will allow characterisation of any further changes in cattle tb incidence, while studies of badger population density, spatial organization, and m. The governments policy is that badger culling should play a role in the control of btb. Evidence shows that badgers are not the primary cause of spreading btb in cattle, and there is robust evidence that culling badgers will in fact make the problem worse due to the perturbation effect the.
A preliminary analysis of the rbct published in december 2005, showed that proactive culling, where most badgers in a particular area were culled, reduced the incidence of bovine tb by 19% within the cull area, although increased it by 29% up to 2 km outside the cull area. Defra is selling the shift to vaccination as the next phase in its policy to eradicate cattle tb. Badger culling has positive and negative effects on bovine tb in cattle and is difficult. The several trials at thornbury, steeple leaze, hartland point and the two trials in ireland1 before the rbct, provide ample evidence of the effectiveness of badger culling in the control of bovine tb btb. Badgers are just the scapegoat for the factory farming of dairy cows and allopathy inc disease racket, shown by their lifespan, culled at 57 years when they can live for over 22. Social perturbation of badger populations following culling has been proposed as an explanation for the failure of culling to consistently. There is a very real risk that culling badgers will exacerbate the spread and incidence of btb in the badger population due to the perturbation effect. Bovine tb and the badger culling debate in britain bovine tb is a chronic respiratory disease in cattle caused by mycobacterium bovis. In northern ireland a 5 year research project is being conducted to test the effects of culling infected badgers and vaccinating noninfected badgers. In scotland, cattle herds are officially tb free and no badger culling takes place. To investigate the impact of repeated widespread badger culling on cattle tb, the. Whether culling badgers can have any meaningful impact on tb incidence remains to be seen, but many authorities are quick to point out that btb is a disease of cattle and it is in cattle that the solution must be found.
340 1384 1417 1555 1332 311 1299 304 1091 903 712 859 554 337 218 1328 1430 248 435 276 648 1307 1335 979 754 423 1154 960 833 970 646 632 220 126 1410 534 1259 1068 228 825